OpenAI’s Solution to 90-Year-Old Math Problem Challenged
OpenAI claims to have solved a 90-year-old math problem, but controversy arises as researchers claim they solved a related problem first.
Intelligence analysis by Qwen 2.5 (3B)
OpenAI and researchers have conflicting claims about solving a 90-year-old math problem. OpenAI says they solved the Navier-Stokes problem, but researchers say they solved a related problem first.
OpenAI and researchers both think they solved a really old math problem. OpenAI says they used a super smart computer to solve it, but the other researchers say they had been working on a related problem for a long time and used their own data to solve it.
Analysis
{"heading_1":"The Navier-Stokes Problem","paragraph_1":"Buckmaster claims that OpenAI is “openly admitting” they used training data from a period after they found their result, which he claims is a violation of their work.","paragraph_2":"Buckmaster also claims that OpenAI is not planning on taking the $1 million prize for solving the Navier-Stokes problem.","paragraph_3":"OpenAI claims they did not access any user data from Codex or Claude to solve the Navier-Stokes problem, but Buckmaster and Alpöge claim they had been working on the related problem for a long time and had access to the necessary data.","heading_2":"OpenAI’s Response","heading_3":"Buckmaster’s Response"}
Key points
- OpenAI claims to have solved the Navier-Stokes problem using an internal AI model
- Researchers claim they solved a related problem first
- OpenAI and researchers disagree on the source of their data
If OpenAI’s solution is verified, it could lead to new advancements in AI and mathematics. If Buckmaster and Alpöge’s solution is verified, it could also lead to new advancements, but in a different area of mathematics.
If OpenAI’s solution is found to be incorrect, it could damage their reputation and the trust in their AI models. If Buckmaster and Alpöge’s solution is found to be incorrect, it could also damage their reputation and the trust in their work.
